As with a number of Taff Ely's places of worship, St Mary's Church, Nantgarw, began as a schoolroom. Henry Williams, the squire of Dyffryn Ffrwd Estate, granted a piece of land to the Archdeacon of Llandaff and a school was built in 1845. The vicar of Eglwysilan was to take responsibility for religious education within the school. The building was also licensed for public worship. By 1875, the building's dual role had ended as it had ceased to function as a school. The church was renovated during the 1890s and much credit is given to Mrs Evan Williams, daughter-in-law of Henry Williams. She held the Sunday School at Dyffryn Ffrwd as well as a sale of work. However, from the 1920s onwards, St Mary's was to encounter problems of debt, a dwindling number of worshipers, and obtaining adequate clerical help. Furthermore, the building of the A470 trunk road resulted in the demolition of the old village and the isolation of the church from the centre of population. St Mary's finally closed in 1983 and became a dwelling house. The congregation joined with St James Church Taff’s Well, the church being rededicated as St Mary and St James Church. Capel Nantgarw, the Welsh Independent Chapel, was located in the centre of the old village. The original building was erected in 1825 but it was later rebuilt. Nantgarw Gospel Hall was erected in the late 1920s with second hand material. The hall remains today and members are anxious to continue to serve Nantgarw, conscious of the fact that it's the last place of worship in the village, Capel Nantgarw having been demolished when the A470 was constructed.
Nantgarw Infants School opened on 11 March 1907 with 55 children on the roll. It was destroyed by fire in April 1933 and pupils were housed in Wheeler's Billiard Hall while the school was rebuilt. The school was reopened on 2 September 1935. An extension providing interior toilets, a small kitchen and an office for the head teacher was built in 1979. The school closed permanently in 2006.